« What more could we ask? | Main | Scattershots - 2jun2010 »

01 June 2010

Comments

RL Crabb

It should be pointed out that many of the innovations realized by technology are born in the imaginations of artists.

George Rebane

A point worth pursuing Bob. We all need to take a look at a list of innovations with such a birthright.

RL Crabb

The most obvious is Da Vinci, who was designing helicopters when he wasn't creating cryptic religious codes in his masterpieces. The communications satellite was imagined by Sci-fi writer Arthur C. Clarke decades before Sputnik. I was watching a program on History called "Star Wars Tech" where an oriental engineer was inspired by the movie to invent a camera that could remotely explore the colon, which proves that I'm not just talking through my ass.

George Rebane

Taking up the challenge Bob, I would offer the following for your examples, while not denying your original premise. Da Vinci was possibly the world's first pure technician and engineer. Like many technicians throughout history, he could also do art. All serious sci-fi writers trained themselves in technology, or were bona fide technicians. The big three - Arthur Clarke, Robert Heinlein, Isaac Asimov - emerging from WW2 were all all solid technicians who could write. Sir Arthur was a radar engineer and instructor before turning to sci-fi. The inspiring Star Wars series and movie had a claim to realism from a number of technical experts who advised George Lucas who himself was originally trained in anthropology segueing into cinematography - a technical undertaking if there ever was one.

Again, I'm not saying that there isn't a technologically innocent artist out there somewhere who might have given the necessary and sufficient nudge to a technical innovation, but we're going to have to go back into search mode to find one.

RL Crabb

Sometimes art is inspired by science and sometimes science is inspired by art. Maybe someday technology will catch up with Rube Goldberg.

By the way, George, sometimes you remind me of a character from a Heinlein novel. Grok that!

George Rebane

Agreed. Speaking of Rube Goldberg, I think that technology has already caught up with and passed the wild complications of that gentlemen - it's called Microsoft Windows.

Yes, sometimes I do feel like a stranger in a strange land.

The comments to this entry are closed.