George Rebane
In these pages we have circled this barn without resolution. My own sentiments, and those of readers at the time, are available here. The politically correct among us regularly encourage all should vote who can fog a mirror and are citizens. Well, not exactly. In recent years the anti-American woke and progressives have reduced that requirement to just the foggers, or even to those who just recently lost that ability.
Bryan Caplan did a landmark study on the electorate and voting – The Myth of the Rational Voter – in which he showed that in our history informed and rational voters were few and far in between. But the saving grace during those times was that the ignorant voter cohort pretty much split themselves evenly on candidates and issues. This left the small percentage of knowledgeable and reasoning voters to essentially determine the outcome by how they divided themselves on the margins. See the top part of the figure below for an explanatory graphic.
All of this changed, beginning around 1920 with the advent of radio broadcasting – the birth of mass media which spread to phone banks, TV, internet, etc. Now it was possible for those with monies to spend to get their messages out in proportion to their available funds. And it turned out that this kind of campaigning worked wonders – the more you could blast out your candidate’s voice, the more assured you were of tilting the scale toward your side among the great unwashed. The small number of knowledgeable and informed voters were overwhelmed, and thereby lost their ability to influence election outcomes. See the bottom part of the figure.
This absence of rational voter influence has had an enormous impact on our country, delivering huge coastal urban areas and even entire states into perpetual social disasters and economic destitution. We now have ignorant cohorts continuing to vote against their own best interests, who guarantee single-party monopolies of entrenched politicians in perpetuity.
Proof of this is provided by a coven of distressed states that includes New York, New Jersey, Illinois, Connecticut, …, headed by its most prominent member, California. The once golden state has been the posterchild of voter ignorance for the last fifty years. Over this period the state’s voters initially ensconced a spate of well-meaning liberal politicians, and then later continued to refill their ranks with know-nothing socialists and charlatans. Today we have sinecured a bevy of functional idiots and scoundrels whose only reliable political talent is using the public till to invite more double dummies (aka reliable constituents) to partake of our insane welfare programs, thereby insuring that California’s recovery remains evermore beyond the horizon. (more here)
So what should a well-meaning but poorly-read citizen do when an election rolls around. My own recommendation is that such a citizen should excuse himself from that particular election, unless he has the ability to educate himself on the candidates and/or issues. And unless you know what is at stake in the election, and how the various outcomes will affect you, your neighbors, the country, stay out of the voting booth but remain interested in the election results and prepare yourself for the next time. If you are a citizen who loves his country, know that it is the voters who determine the state of the nation and its future. So just because you have the right to vote, there is no law that requires you to cast an ignorant vote based on what you saw on TV the most, the loudest, or the most recent. (more here)
Today my counsel is considered elitist and even anti-American by those who want everyone to vote regardless of their preparation. (See the exhortations in our local newspaper.) They tell you that democracy is intrinsically strengthened by high voter turnouts. History shows us that nothing could be further from the truth – democracies inevitably ended their lives by suicides through emotional plebiscites, referendums, and other summarily catastrophic ballot box ‘opportunities’. So, get informed first, then vote.
"My own recommendation is that such a citizen should excuse himself from that particular election, unless he has the ability to educate himself on the candidates and/or issues. "
There's also no rule that says you have to vote on every single office, every single proposition.
Posted by: scenes | 04 June 2022 at 10:40 AM
scenes 1040am - That too; thanks.
Posted by: George Rebane | 04 June 2022 at 03:11 PM
Is today the day I open my ballot and mail it in from another county?
Posted by: Bill Tozer | 06 June 2022 at 09:42 AM
Probably "knee jerk" but saw a headline implying LA& San Fram might drift right? As goes CA as goes the nation???
Posted by: Randy | 07 June 2022 at 12:58 PM
is today the day I can open my ballot?
Posted by: Bill Tozer | 07 June 2022 at 01:08 PM
Randy 1258pm - From your mouth to God's ear.
Posted by: George Rebane | 07 June 2022 at 01:12 PM
"implying LA& San Fram might drift right?"
Yeah - from completely lunatic left to only very much lunatic left.
At the rate they're going, CA might get back to circa 1980 by 2080. If that would be possible.
And that would still be solidly left.
Any questions?
Posted by: Scott O | 07 June 2022 at 09:59 PM